
Various areas of life are affected in the most diverse ways by the criminal offense of coercion.
As an omnipresent societal phenomenon, so-called “climate gluers” have, for example, been making headlines for quite some time. Consequently, questions regarding the legality of road blockades involving adhesive have occupied the courts for years. In this context, the inherent tension between such actions and the constitutionally protected freedom of assembly under Art. 8 of the Basic Law (GG) raises a wide range of questions, particularly during demonstrations. As with climate protests, a differentiation must also be made in nationwide farmers’ protestsor trucker protestsas to whether the primary motive was an unlawful road blockade amounting to criminal coercion under Section 240 of the German Criminal Code (StGB) or a legitimate manifestation of public opinion.
Yet even away from the streets, the statutory offense is subject to ongoing legal and political debate. For instance, discussions surrounding the criminality of so-called “catcalling“ are intensifying. Since inappropriate, sexually intrusive remarks can currently neither be prosecuted under Sections 174 et seq. of the German Criminal Code (StGB)—which only penalize physical sexual harassment—nor cross the threshold of a legally actionable insult under Federal Court of Justice (BGH) case law when framed as expressions of intent to engage in sexual intercourse, calls are growing to broaden the statutory offense of coercion. Expanding this offense could encompass “catcalling” in the future and thereby close existing loopholes in criminal liability.
Furthermore, efforts are underway to utilize the statutory offense of coercion to counter instances of organized crime involving threats against witnesses, judges, and expert witnesses. This approach could be implemented by expanding the statutory aggravation examples (Regelbeispiele) for coercion.
Coercion – Key Facts at a Glance
Means of Coercion:Coercion can be committed through the use of force (violence) or by threat of serious harm. The latter, in particular, fundamentally opens a broad scope of application for the statutory offense.
Assessment of Culpability / Unlawfulness (Verwerflichkeitsprüfung):Coercion is unlawful only if the use of force or the threat of harm is deemed reprehensible in relation to the intended objective. Consequently, unlawfulness must be positively established in cases of coercion.
Statutory Examples of Especially Serious Cases:An especially serious case of coercion may occur if the perpetrator coerces a pregnant woman into terminating a pregnancy or abuses their authority or position as a public official.
Received a Police Summons for Alleged Coercion
If you have received a police summons for alleged coercion, it is critical to avoid any hasty actions. You should remain calm and, above all, not attend an interrogation as an accused before consulting a defense attorney. As an accused person in preliminary investigative proceedings for coercion pursuant to Section 240 StGB, you are under no obligation to make any statement to the police. Whether attending the interrogation might be advisable in your specific case can be evaluated by a criminal defense attorney. The criminal offense of coercion can arise in a wide variety of factual scenarios. While there may be situations where criminal liability for coercion does not seem obvious to the perpetrator—leading the offense to occasionally be perceived as a minor infraction—there are blatant cases, such as threatening to kill someone’s child, where the criminal nature of the conduct is immediately apparent to anyone. These highly diverse factual situations are flexibly accounted for by the sentencing range for coercion, which extends from a monetary fine to three years’ imprisonment. As highly experienced criminal defense lawyers, we are here to assist you if you are facing allegations of coercion. Following an initial legal assessment and foundational consultation, we will develop a customized defense strategy tailored to your needs.
The Statutory Elements of Section 240 StGB
The objective elements of Section 240 (1) StGB primarily consist of an eligible act of coercion—in the form of force or the threat of serious harm—and a resulting coercive outcome. From a subjective perspective, Section 240 (1) StGB requires intentional conduct. A particular aspect to be assessed in the context of coercion is unlawfulness: unlike in standard criminal offenses where meeting the statutory elements generally implies unlawfulness, the unlawfulness of coercion must be positively determined via an assessment of reprehensibility (Verwerflichkeitsprüfung). Finally, coercion can be committed as an especially serious case. Such a case typically arises when the perpetrator coerces a pregnant woman into having an abortion or abuses their powers or position as a public official, pursuant to Section 240 (4) sentence 2 nos. 1 and 2 StGB. The statutory offense of coercion protects an individual’s freedom of will formationas well as their freedom of action.
The Objective Elements of Section 240 (1) StGB
Pursuant to Section 240 (1) StGB, whoever unlawfully coerces another person into an act, omission, or toleration of an act through force or by threat of serious harm shall be punished with imprisonment not exceeding three years or with a monetary fine. Accordingly, the object of the offense—another person—must be compelled toward a coerced result by means of coercion.
Means of Coercion under Section 240 (1) StGB – Force or Threat of Serious Harm
The definition of force within Section 240 (1) StGB, which remains disputed in its specific details, essentially requires physical force , which can be implemented in the form of vis absoluta(absolute force that entirely eliminates free will, rendering the victim’s formation and execution of will impossible) or vis compulsiva(compulsive force that bends the victim’s will, steering the execution of their intent). The requisite physical component means that coercive acts that operate purely on a psychological level (such as online demonstrations) are not covered by the concept of force under Section 240 (1) StGB. Depending on the specific case, force committed by omission, directed against third parties, or directed against property can also fulfill the statutory elements. Similarly, the means of coercion constituted by a threat of serious harm—which can also be committed by omission—can take many forms. A threat refers to forecasting future harm over whose occurrence the perpetrator claims or purports to exercise influence. Harm in this context encompasses any detriment or disadvantage. The harm is considered serious if, viewed objectively and taking into account the personal circumstances of the victim, it is capable of causing a reasonable person to yield to the demanded conduct. In this respect, the victim can reasonably be expected to demonstrate a certain level of resistance “in measured self-assertion.”Threatened harm may also be considered serious even if the threatened act is not itself criminal. Conversely, not every threat of a criminal offense automatically fulfills the definition of coercion; it must always be evaluated in relation to the objective pursued in the specific case. Examples recognized as satisfying the statutory elements include threats to terrorize another person with excessive noise or to deliberately infect them with HIV. Conversely, the mere notification of an intent to file an official disciplinary complaint or forecasting further professional difficulties is generally considered insufficient.
The Coercive Result under Section 240 (1) StGB – Act, Toleration, or Omission
The means of coercion—force or threat of serious harm—must result in a coerced outcome in the form of an act, toleration, or omission. A certain degree of independence between the means of coercion and the coercive result is required. This entails that the demanded act, toleration, or omission must extend beyond the immediate impairment inherently associated with the application of force. For instance, it does not suffice to identify the coercive outcome merely in the passive toleration of force that constitutes bodily injury. Furthermore, causation must exist between the coercive act and the resulting outcome.
The Subjective Elements of Section 240 StGB
Coercion is an intentional offense. To fulfill the statutory elements, the perpetrator must act with at least conditional intent (dolus eventualis) regarding the realization of all objective elements.
Reprehensibility / Unlawfulness of Coercion, Section 240 (2) StGB
Pursuant to Section 240 (2) StGB, coercion is unlawful if the use of force or the threat of harm is deemed reprehensible in relation to the desired purpose. This provision represents a significant departure from the basic structure of criminal law. Unlike standard offenses, the unlawfulnessof the act is not presumed merely because no grounds of justification exist. Rather, the unlawfulness of coercion must be positively established through an assessment of reprehensibility (Verwerflichkeitsprüfung)in order to curtail criminal liability in light of the broad spectrum of potential threats of serious harm and to safeguard the constitutionally protected general freedom of action of the individual. Under the wording of Section 240 (2) StGB, the standard for establishing reprehensibility is the relationship between the means of coercion and the intended purpose. Both components are weighed against each other, and on this basis, the presence (or absence) of unlawfulness is determined. This not only gives rise to an area of law heavily shaped by case-by-case jurisprudence, but also accommodates fundamental questions of legal doctrine and legal policy—such as taking into account long-term objectives (such as climate protection) or the potential lawfulness of demonstrations given their fundamental constitutional protection under Article 5 and Article 8 of the Basic Law (GG). It is evident that the substantial scope for argument and the necessity of a meticulous case-by-case assessmentprovide an ideal foundation for experienced criminal defense attorneys to effectively challenge sufficient suspicion of criminal coercion.
Especially Serious Cases of Coercion, Section 240 (4) StGB
Finally, the statutory offense of coercion can also occur in the form of an especially serious case. Pursuant to Section 240 (4) sentence 2 StGB, an especially serious case typically occurs when the perpetrator
- coerces a pregnant woman into terminating a pregnancy, or
- abuses their authority or position as a public official.
The codification of coercing an abortion as an especially serious case primarily serves to enhance the protection of pregnant women against unreasonable pressure from their social environment. Threatening to breach statutory maintenance obligations, for instance, would constitute a criminal act in this context. Conversely, an abuse of authority by a public official (Section 11 (1) no. 2 StGB) is assumed when an official acting within the scope of their competencies exercises them in a manner contrary to duty or the law. An abuse of position already exists where the perpetrator arrogates powers not vested in them to use them as a means of coercion in pursuit of a specific coercive objective.
Potential Sentencing Range upon Conviction for Coercion
Coercion pursuant to Section 240 (1) StGB is punishable by a monetary fine or imprisonment of up to three years. Pursuant to Section 240 (3) StGB, the attempt is also punishable. An especially serious case of coercion under Section 240 (4) sentence 2 StGB can be reflected at sentencing by an increased statutory range: pursuant to Section 240 (4) sentence 1 StGB, imprisonment in especially serious cases ranges from six months to five years. For coercion as well, the specific sentence imposed depends heavily on the circumstances of the individual case. Alongside the facts of the offense, any prior convictions of the perpetrator have a substantial impact on the severity of the sentence. Furthermore, there is the potential of an entry in the certificate of conduct (criminal record). Generally, monetary fines are only recorded if they exceed 90 daily penalty units, or prison sentences exceeding three months, provided no other penalties are registered. Since many employers require the submission of a certificate of conduct, we, as criminal defense attorneys, place particular emphasis on keeping the penalty below the threshold of 90 daily units whenever possible.
Do I Need an Attorney?
To mitigate a heavier sentence or, ideally, avoid a conviction altogether, you should be represented by a specialized attorney if you are accused in criminal proceedings for coercion. Depending on the specific factual situation, criminal liability for coercion can lead to severe penalties. We see it as our responsibility to provide you with the best possible counsel and to prevent these consequences wherever feasible.

