
Key Facts About Defense in Juvenile Criminal Proceedings
- Juvenile Criminal Law: It applies to juveniles (ages 14-17) and, in individual cases, to young adults (ages 18-20). The focus is on education rather than punishment.
- Typical Juvenile Offenses: Common crimes include theft, assault, trespassing, and traffic offenses.
- Defense Strategies: The goal is often the dismissal of the case. Alternatives include diversion (waiving prosecution), educational measures, or victim-offender mediation.
- Special Features: Juvenile Court Assistance is involved, and the public is excluded from hearings to ensure the protection of privacy rights.
- Juvenile Sentence: This is only imposed as a last resort, e.g., for serious crimes or harmful inclinations, and ranges from 6 months to 5 years (up to 15 years in particularly serious cases).
- Public Defense: Juveniles are assigned a public defender more frequently than adults, especially when facing juvenile sentences or deprivation of liberty.
What happens to juveniles who commit offenses?
In juvenile criminal law especially, the early appointment of an expert criminal defense attorney is crucial, as juveniles and young adults have special legal protection needs within the proceedings. We want to ensure that these are taken into account and that fair treatment is guaranteed in order to enforce your rights in the best possible way.
If you are involved in criminal proceedings yourself as a juvenile or young adult, or if your child is an accused in criminal proceedings and you do not know what to do, it is best to contact us immediately so that we can explain the best way to proceed.
In most cases, the primary goal is, of course, the dismissal of the proceedings while still at the investigation stage. If this is no longer possible, there are numerous alternative options for us as defense attorneys in juvenile criminal law to achieve the mildest possible sanction.
Juvenile Delinquency – Cause for Concern or Normality?
According to police crime statistics, 21% of the crimes committed in 2023 were committed by juveniles. Young people therefore commit crimes quite frequently.
In most cases, this happens regardless of their family background or nationality, but rather due to their physical-biological development and existing psycho-social burdens. Young offenders are in a biological, psychological, and social stage of transition, which is often accompanied by tension, uncertainty, and difficulties in adjustment, particularly regarding the acquisition of behavioral norms.
In the vast majority of cases, criminal behavior is only temporary and ends on its own once the juvenile’s maturation process is complete.
Typical juvenile offenses include, for example, theft, assault, robbery, trespassing, and especially traffic offenses.
When a juvenile commits a crime, they are not sentenced to a fine or imprisonment as is the case in adult criminal law; instead, juvenile criminal law applies, which entails a wider range of possible educational measures. The reason for this is the increased sensitivity of juvenile criminal law as such, as well as the special needs of juveniles, which must also be taken into account regarding the severity of the sentence.
When does juvenile criminal law apply?
According to § 1 JGG, juvenile criminal law applies when a juvenile or a young adult commits a misconduct (felony or misdemeanor) that is punishable under general regulations.
A juvenile is defined as someone who is 14 but not yet 18 years old at the time of the offense. A young adult is someone who is 18 but not yet 21 years old.

Juveniles are only “conditionally criminally responsible” according to § 3 JGG. This means that it must be positively determined whether the individual juvenile was mature enough to be responsible at the time the offense was committed. This is generally the case if the presence of so-called capacity for insight and capacity for action can be affirmed. The capacity for insight consists of ethical maturity, intellectual maturity, and the presence of an awareness of wrongdoing. Capacity for action means the ability to align one’s own behavior according to one’s own insight.
Young adults are criminally responsible in any case. Whether juvenile criminal law or adult criminal law applies to a young adult is decided on a case-by-case basis. Relevant factors include the state of maturity the young adult had at the time of the offense and whether they were still equivalent to a juvenile in the specific offense, for example, because a typical juvenile offense was committed.
From the age of 21, adult criminal law applies exclusively; the application of juvenile criminal law is excluded.
Defense Options – No Punishment?
In the context of defending juveniles and young adults, it is particularly important to conduct an early initial consultation to explain the criminal process and its associated peculiarities to the young client, who is still developing, to protect their interests, ensure fair and appropriate treatment of the juvenile, and achieve the best possible result for them together. Particular emphasis is placed on the young client’s life situation and future plans in order to better predict the sanction and corresponding legal behavior.
Juvenile criminal law offers a variety of sanction options, most notably educational measures, disciplinary measures, and juvenile sentences. Within the sanctions, the principle of subsidiarity applies. This means that, as a rule, an educational measure must first be imposed as a milder sanction before any disciplinary measures or even the imposition of a juvenile sentence can be considered.
When it comes to an allegation of a serious crime and an acquittal seems impossible, we as criminal defense attorneys will work toward the mildest possible sanction – the imposition of an educational measure.
As criminal defense attorneys in juvenile criminal law, we first check whether the requirements for a dismissal of the proceedings are met. In addition, we advise the juvenile or young adult and, if applicable, their legal guardians on what they can do to have the proceedings dismissed. A dismissal is generally always considered if the offender has no prior convictions, their guilt is considered minor, and there is no public interest in prosecution.
Diversion – Waiving the Prosecution of the Offense
If an “ordinary dismissal” is not considered or seems hopeless, we strive for a termination of proceedings in accordance with the “diversion regulations.” A diversion can result in waiving the prosecution of the offense and thus avoid a juvenile criminal law reaction through a judgment, provided that educational influence is guaranteed within the framework of §§ 45, 47 JGG.
According to § 45 para. 1 JGG, the public prosecutor’s office can waive punishment if it is a first-time offense by the offender involving typical juvenile misconduct with a low degree of guilt and no special educational measures are required.
Otherwise, the possibility of § 45 para. 2 JGG exists. According to this, waiving the penalty is appropriate if an educational measure has already been carried out or initiated against the juvenile/young adult that influences the juvenile in such a way that the involvement of the juvenile judge is no longer necessary. Educational measures can be, for example, sanctions by parents, the school, or Juvenile Court Assistance.
Furthermore, according to § 45 para. 3 JGG, there is the possibility of terminating the proceedings if the young offender admits the alleged wrong they are said to have committed and the issuance of a directive or condition is ordered. Conditions include, for example, performing community service, mediation with the victim, or paying a sum of money to a non-profit organization.
Victim-Offender Mediation
Another strategic defense option is so-called victim-offender mediation. The primary goal here is restitution. The mediation is carried out between the alleged offender and the victim through an apology by the alleged offender, a discussion, reconciliation, or an admission. The victim should regain a sense of control through the mediation (victim protection). However, victim-offender mediation can only be considered for minor to moderate crimes. In the event that the mediation can be successfully completed, the proceedings are dismissed by the public prosecutor’s office.
Out-of-Court Settlement – Agreement and Arrangement
In some cases, it may also be useful to seek an agreement with the court and the public prosecutor’s office regarding the outcome of the proceedings. In this case, the juvenile or young adult would have to agree to fulfill certain conditions.
Another task on our part is to prevent or, in any case, mitigate the negative consequences of the sentence and the trial. Possible negative consequences include, for example, compensation payments to the victim, potential termination of employment, a negative criminal record, or possible consequences under immigration law.
When may a juvenile sentence be imposed?
According to § 17 para. 2 of the Juvenile Court Act (JGG), a juvenile sentence is generally only used as a last resort in juvenile criminal law. Deprivation of liberty should only be ordered if, due to the “harmful inclinations of the juvenile, educational measures or disciplinary measures are not sufficient for education, or if a sentence is necessary due to the gravity of the guilt.”.
However, the term “harmful inclinations” is very outdated and imprecise. It primarily refers to significant dispositional or educational deficiencies which, without a longer period of overall education of the offender – through a juvenile sentence – create the danger of further crimes. As a rule, this requires that serious personality defects of the offender were already present before the offense. In individual cases, a juvenile sentence may also be necessary due to the gravity of the guilt. Decisive for the assessment are the circumstances of the offender’s personal guilt, their character, their personality, and the motivation for the crime, which are reflected in the guilt.
As a rule, however, the competent juvenile judge will only impose a juvenile sentence if all other educational options have already been tried or appear hopeless from the outset. The background to this is the design of juvenile criminal law as educational criminal law. The educational concept is always the reason, the justification, and the limit for the application of juvenile criminal law. The primary goal of juvenile criminal law is to prevent the juvenile or young adult from re-offending, also to protect the general public. However, every measure of juvenile criminal law also represents a sanction and, for you as the person affected, means an interference with your freedom.
The juvenile sentence is considered the most severe measure of juvenile criminal law. The minimum sentence is 6 months and the maximum is 5 years. The background to this is also the educational concept and the associated assumption that inpatient education cannot promise success in a period of less than 6 months or more than 5 years.
Despite this, in individual cases, a prison sentence of up to 15 years can occur. This is why a good criminal defense is indispensable in any case.
Special Features in Juvenile Criminal Proceedings
A special feature of juvenile criminal proceedings is the involvement of Juvenile Court Assistance and their possible questioning of the juvenile. Juvenile Court Assistance is a department of the Youth Welfare Office (Jugendamt) that supports juveniles before, during, and after the court hearing and is intended to represent educational and social aspects in the proceedings. The employees of Juvenile Court Assistance are not bound by confidentiality toward the court. However, the juvenile or young adult is also not obliged to participate in such a discussion. Participation can, however, be advantageous. We also advise you regarding this decision, explaining the advantages and disadvantages.
As soon as proceedings are initiated against the juvenile, the parents or legal guardians also have a right to be heard, to ask questions or file motions, or to be present during investigative acts.
In the context of proceedings against a juvenile or young adult, there is also usually public interest. This often leads to increased pressure from the investigative authorities, which should not, however, result in a disadvantage for the juvenile.
To enable extensive protection of the defendant’s personality, the public is excluded from the main hearing. The same applies to press and image reporting. Neither photos nor the name of the defendant or other information suitable for identifying them may be published. To ensure that this is guaranteed, we as defense attorneys will take all necessary measures.
Appointment of a Public Defender
The appointment of a necessary defense attorney/public defender occurs significantly more frequently in juvenile criminal matters than in adult criminal law. Juveniles or young adults who have committed a crime are often in a financially precarious or socially less competent situation and are dependent on the appointment.
In addition to the grounds for appointment under § 140 StPO, which also apply in adult criminal law, a public defender must be appointed for the juvenile or young adult especially if the imposition of a juvenile sentence is being considered or if the order of placement in a psychiatric hospital or a detoxification center is to be expected. Another reason exists if the legal guardians can no longer participate in the proceedings due to suspicion of involvement in the crime or for reasons of state security.
Furthermore, a defense attorney must be appointed for the juvenile in any case if they are already serving pre-trial detention or temporary placement.
The law firm Mügge, Dr. Pitschel & Partner is excellently positioned in the field of juvenile criminal law and has many years of practical experience. We strive at all times for a dismissal of the proceedings to prevent a burdensome main hearing. If you have any questions, please feel free to contact us.

