Delay in filing for insolvency – what managing directors need to know now

November 29, 2024
|
in Criminal Law
|
by Dr. Anthea Pitschel

Delay in filing for insolvency – Key points at a glance

  • Definition: A delay in filing for insolvency occurs when the insolvency petition is not filed in a timely manner despite the occurrence of insolvency readiness. Insolvency readiness exists in cases of illiquidity (§ 17 InsO), imminent illiquidity (§ 18 InsO), or over-indebtedness (§ 19 InsO). Who is affected? Only managing directors of legal entities (e.g., GmbH, AG, UG, GmbH & Co. KG, commercial associations or foundations, foreign corporations with a registered office in Germany). The obligation to file does not apply to sole proprietors or freelancers – though other criminal law risks (e.g., bankruptcy) do apply.
  • Legal basis: § 15a para. 1–5 InsO Deadlines for the insolvency petition: 3 weeks in the event of illiquidity or imminent illiquidity 6 weeks in the event of over-indebtedness. The decisive factor is not subjective knowledge, but the point in time at which the crisis was recognizable with proper management.
  • Penalties: Intent: Imprisonment for up to 3 years or a fine
  • Negligence: Imprisonment for up to 1 year or a fine
  • Civil law: Personal liability with private assets possible
  • Statute of limitations: 5 years for intentional delay in filing for insolvency 3 years for negligent delay in filing for insolvency
  • Delay in filing for insolvency is one of the most common, but also most misunderstood, criminal offenses in white-collar criminal law. Managing directors of small and medium-sized corporations in particular underestimate how quickly they can fall within the scope of § 15a InsO and how serious the consequences can be. This involves not only criminal consequences but also personal liability, damage to reputation, and the end of one’s professional career.
  • This article explains in a clear and practical way what matters and how managing directors can effectively protect themselves.

Who is affected? Obligation to file only for certain company forms

Delay in filing for insolvency is not a risk for all entrepreneurs equally. Only certain forms of companies are affected – above all, corporations. The obligation to file for insolvency according to § 15a InsO applies to:

  • GmbH (including UG with limited liability)
  • AG
  • GmbH & Co. KG
  • Ltd. (with administrative headquarters in Germany)
  • Foundations and commercial associations
  • Legal entities under public law (under certain conditions)

Not affected by the obligation to file for insolvency under § 15a InsO are sole proprietorships, freelancers, the GbR, or the OHG—i.e., companies in which natural persons have unlimited personal liability. These entrepreneurs may voluntarily file for insolvency in the event of illiquidity or over-indebtedness, but they are not legally obliged to do so.

Caution: Even without an obligation to file, other civil or criminal law risks may exist – particularly if new debts are incurred or creditors are disadvantaged despite a hopeless situation.

What does insolvency readiness mean? The three decisive grounds for insolvency

One speaks of insolvency readiness when a company is illiquid or over-indebted, i.e., it can no longer meet its due liabilities or its assets no longer cover its debts.

At this moment, the management of a corporation (e.g., GmbH or AG) must immediately file for insolvency.

If this petition is not filed despite insolvency readiness, the offense of delay in filing for insolvency is committed (§ 15a InsO).

An obligation to file therefore does not arise arbitrarily, but only if one of the legally defined grounds for insolvency exists. These are:

1. Illiquidity (§ 17 InsO)

The most common case: The company can no longer meet its due liabilities and no short-term improvement is in sight. According to the Federal Court of Justice (BGH), illiquidity exists if less than 90% of the due liabilities can be covered on a permanent basis. In practice, a period of approx. 3 weeks is used as a benchmark.

2. Imminent illiquidity (§ 18 InsO)

This requires that the company will most likely no longer be able to meet its due payments in the near future. This involves a liquidity forecast over a period of up to 24 months. Important: Only the debtor themselves (not the creditors) can file for insolvency in the event of imminent illiquidity – it is therefore a subjective right, not an obligation.

3. Over-indebtedness (§ 19 InsO)

In the case of corporations, there is also an obligation to file in the event of over-indebtedness – i.e., when assets no longer cover existing liabilities and there is no positive forecast for the continuation of the company. For this purpose, annual financial statements, projected balance sheets, and continuation forecasts must be prepared regularly. Over-indebtedness is one of the most complex grounds for insolvency, but it is often underestimated.

Insolvency filing deadlines: Illiquidity vs. Over-indebtedness

Overview of insolvency filing deadlines

From the time of insolvency readiness, the statutory deadline runs (§ 15a para. 1 InsO). And this deadline is tight:

  • Illiquidity: Petition within 3 weeks
  • Over-indebtedness: Petition within 6 weeks

Caution: The deadline does not only begin when the managing director “subjectively recognizes” that the company is illiquid. The decisive factor is the point in time at which he should have recognized it upon dutiful examination. Anyone who closes their eyes to reality or relies on gut feeling instead of liquidity planning may already be acting with gross negligence.

Typical errors in practice

Daily consulting practice shows: Most managing directors do not commit a delay in filing for insolvency out of malicious intent, but out of ignorance or false hope.

The most common errors include:

  • Confusion between temporary payment stagnation and illiquidity Many entrepreneurs assume that a short-term bottleneck is not an insolvency. However, as soon as no realistic coverage is in sight, even a seemingly “temporary” crisis can become relevant under insolvency law.
  • “I am working on a restructuring, so the deadline doesn’t count yet” Wrong. Restructuring efforts are only permissible within the deadline. If the situation is hopeless from the outset, the deadline begins immediately.
  • “I left that to my tax advisor” A common but dangerous misconception. The responsibility lies with the managing director; delegation is not possible. Even a mistake regarding the legal situation does not automatically exonerate you.
  • “I didn’t want to worry my employees” Humanly understandable, but legally irrelevant. At the latest when illiquidity is imminent, concrete measures must be taken.

What are the threats in the event of a delay in filing for insolvency?

The legal consequences are serious – both under criminal and civil law.

Criminal law (§ 15a para. 4 and 5 InsO):

  • Intentional delay in filing for insolvency: up to 3 years imprisonment or a fine
  • Negliggent delay in filing for insolvency: up to 1 year imprisonment or a fine
  • Professional ban possible (e.g., 5-year ban on acting as a managing director)
  • Entry in the certificate of conduct from 91 daily penalty units or 3 months imprisonment

Civil law:

  • Personal liability of the managing director for damages resulting from the late filing of the insolvency petition
  • Claims for damages by creditors, social security, tax office
  • Liability with private assets possible

De facto managing directors can also be liable:

The obligations under § 15a InsO do not only apply to formally appointed managing directors. Persons who actually act like a managing director – for example, through independent decisions, payment instructions, or instructions to employees – can be held personally liable as so-called de facto managing directors.

Case study from practice

A managing director of a GmbH recognizes liquidity problems but waits for the conclusion of a promotional loan. This is not approved, yet he only files for insolvency two months later. Result: Penal order for 120 daily units at €60 each, entry in the certificate of conduct, 5-year ban on acting as a managing director. In addition, there are liability claims from the health insurance fund in the amount of €25,000.

Act early: What managing directors should do

Delay in filing for insolvency is avoidable in many cases – provided that one acts in a timely and responsible manner. The following measures have proven effective:

1. Establish an early warning system

Liquidity planning, weekly payment overviews, forecast calculations – those who know their numbers recognize insolvency readiness early.

2. Separation of business and private assets

Proper bookkeeping and separate accounts create transparency and facilitate documentation in an emergency.

3. Seek advice

In case of doubt, involve a specialized lawyer or tax advisor early on. Those who come early can still shape the outcome – those who come too late risk liability.

4. Document everything

Be sure to record discussions with creditors, banks, or advisors in writing. This can be decisive later for the assessment of intent or negligence.

5. Exercise responsibility

Even if several managing directors are appointed: each is personally liable. It is not enough to rely on colleagues or the accounting department.

Conclusion: Avoid delay in filing for insolvency – through clarity, control, and consistency

Delay in filing for insolvency is not a fate that surprises managing directors – but is usually the result of hesitation, uncertainty, and false assumptions. Those who act early, recognize risks, and seek professional advice can not only avoid a criminal offense but also save the company or hand it over in an orderly fashion.

On the other hand, those who close their eyes to reality or pin their hopes on a “spontaneous turnaround” risk not only legal consequences but often also their professional future.

Table of Contents
Consultation via Video Conference
Our attorneys provide personal consultations regardless of your location – via secure video conferencing, throughout Germany.
Schedule an Appointment
Ihr Kontakt zu uns

Schildern Sie uns Ihren Fall vertrau­lich

Schildern Sie kurz, was passiert ist und ob Fristen oder Termine laufen. Wir melden uns in der Regel innerhalb von 24 Stunden, um das weitere Vorgehen und die benötigten Unterlagen zu klären.
Call directly
The information provided in the contact form will be collected and processed. Your data is transmitted in encrypted form and will not be shared with third parties.