
In its order of April 19, 2023, 2 BvR 2180/20, the Federal Constitutional Court declared unconstitutional the search of the private residence in Dortmund belonging to suspected clan member Sammy Miri, which had been ordered by the Local Court of Hagen in August 2020.
The Federal Constitutional Court’s decision is centrally grounded on the finding that the search unlawfully infringed upon the accused’s fundamental right to the inviolability of the home under Article 13 of the Basic Law.
The residential search arose in connection with preliminary investigation proceedings concerning suspected money laundering and other offenses.
These proceedings were purportedly connected to further investigations against an accused named K. on suspicion of commercial fraud, who was alleged, among other things, to have ties to Miri. Those ties were said to primarily involve two companies operated by K. (A.-UG and B.-UG).
On August 12, 2020, the police searched Miri himself, his residential premises, other rooms on the property including the associated items and containers, outbuildings, motor vehicles, and garages.
The objective of the search included discovering evidence “of expenditures in connection with A. UG and B. UG as well as the source of these funds, of possible agreements between the parties involved, as well as documents, mobile phones, data storage media, computers, and other recording media.”
After Miri unsuccessfully lodged an appeal against the search warrant, he filed a constitutional complaint on December 11, 2020, represented by his legal counsel, asserting a violation of Article 13 of the Basic Law.
Article 13(1) of the Basic Law guarantees the inviolability of the home. A search constitutes a—typically—severe intrusion into this constitutionally protected personal sphere of life.
In its ruling, the Federal Constitutional Court first set out the requirements for a justified intrusion into the inviolability of the home, and thus for a lawful search:
“A necessary, but also—in view of the severity of the intrusion entailed by a residential search—sufficient basis for a search is the suspicion that a criminal offense has been committed. The gravity of the intrusion requires grounds for suspicion based on specific facts that go beyond vague indications and mere suppositions […]. A search must therefore not serve to uncover facts that are only necessary to establish an initial suspicion in the first place […].”
Furthermore, “the warrant must delineate the alleged criminal offense and the evidence sought in such a manner that the external framework within which the coercive measure is executed is clearly established. […] In this way, the individual concerned is simultaneously placed in a position to monitor the search and counter any exceeding of authority from the outset […]. The essential elements of the statutory offense that characterize the criminal liability of the conduct to be subsumed must be stated […].”
In the view of the Federal Constitutional Court, there was an absence of both these specific facts and adequate limits to the search warrant:
“Insofar as the specialized courts based the search warrant on the suspicion of money laundering pursuant to Section 261(1) of the Criminal Code (old version), the underlying factual indications did not extend beyond vague connections and mere suppositions.”
The order of the Local Court was found to contain scarcely any substantive statements regarding the origin of the disguised assets and the predicate offenses under Section 261(1) of the Criminal Code—neither the suspicion of tax evasion nor alleged “violent crime” or purported drug trafficking had been specified in detail, and thus could not substantiate an initial suspicion.
Furthermore, the measurability and controllability of the execution were not ensured due to the lack of specification of the alleged predicate offenses and the evidence sought.
The Federal Constitutional Court’s decision demonstrates: searches are precisely not intended to investigate individuals’ homes in an unbounded manner in the hope of constructing an initial suspicion—this applies equally to suspected clan members.
Challenging the legality of the ordering and execution of a search by way of an appeal can often serve as an effective means of defending oneself against such state coercive measures.

