
It is not uncommon for individuals to find themselves in pre-trial detention even though they never committed the crime of which they are accused. In Germany, pre-trial detention is wrongfully ordered in many cases – usually with severe consequences for the detainee.
The accused is often abruptly torn from their life, with no opportunity to prepare for detention. As a result, they not only face the emotional strain of imprisonment and separation from their family, but at times must also deal with the worry of losing their job or home due to incarceration. Even after being released from pre-trial detention, most individuals can never forget the experience; they carry a stigma and are frequently traumatized.
Pre-trial detention constitutes a severe encroachment on the constitutionally protected fundamental freedoms of the accused, who—by virtue of the presumption of innocence—is presumed innocent until a final, legally binding judgment is rendered.
Precisely because detention can lead to substantial hardship and grave consequences, the statutory requirements for this procedural coercive measure must be examined with particular rigor by the court, and pre-trial detention may only be ordered as an ultima ratio.
The objective of pre-trial detention is to secure the presence of the accused at trial, guarantee the establishment of the facts, and ensure the potential subsequent enforcement of a sentence.
Pursuant to Section 112 (1) of the German Code of Criminal Procedure (StPO), there must be strong suspicion that the perpetrator committed a criminal offense, a statutory ground for detention (flight, risk of flight, risk of tampering with evidence, or danger of re-offending) must exist, and the order of pre-trial detention must be proportionate.
A strong suspicion exists when, based on the investigation to date, concrete facts give rise to a high probability that the perpetrator has unlawfully and culpably committed a criminal offense or was an accomplice in the commission of an offense.
In most cases, the order for pre-trial detention is based on the statutory ground of risk of flight. But what constitutes such a risk of flight, and what legal requirements must be met to establish it?
A risk of flight is primarily assumed when an assessment of all circumstances of the individual case makes it more probable that the accused will evade the criminal proceedings rather than remain available for them.
In this context, the assumption of a risk of flight must not be based on conjecture, but must arise from specific facts. The mere fact that flight is “conceivable”—for example, because the accused is a foreign national and could therefore have ties abroad—is just as insufficient to establish a risk of flight as the assumption that the accused lives in precarious financial circumstances.
What is required is a comprehensive balancing of all factors arguing for and against an imminent risk of flight. Relevant circumstances primarily include the nature of the offense with which the accused is charged, the personality of the accused, their living conditions, their prior history, as well as their conduct before and after the offense. In particular, any significant incentive to flee arising from the expected severity of the sentence must also be taken into account.
Detainees can often regain their freedom only through a criminal defense attorney who fights for their release. Available legal remedies to challenge an arrest warrant include an application for judicial review of detention (Section 117 (1) in conjunction with Section 118 StPO) and an appeal against detention (Section 304 StPO).
Within the scope of both legal remedies, it is of vital importance to present arguments that weigh against upholding the arrest warrant or in favor of suspending its execution.
In the event that the order for pre-trial detention is determined to have been unlawful, the wrongfully detained individuals may assert a claim for financial compensation under the German Law on Compensation for Criminal Prosecution Measures (StrEG). The statutory compensation currently stands at 75 euros per day of detention—a small comfort for those who have been wrongfully held in pre-trial detention.
Should you have any further questions or if you are accused in criminal proceedings or tax proceedings (criminal tax proceedings), please do not hesitate to contact us.

