Tax Advisors and Delayed Insolvency Filings: Advisor Liability for Insolvency Delay Damages in 2025

April 3, 2025
|
in Criminal Law
|
by Dr. Anthea Pitschel

Advisor Liability for Delayed Insolvency Filings – A Brief Overview

  • Liability risk for advisors: Tax advisors and attorneys can be held liable for failing to provide notice when a client reaches a state of insolvency and in cases of delayed insolvency filings
  • Civil and criminal consequences: Potential aiding and abetting of a delayed insolvency filing with severe ramifications
  • Documentation duty: Specific advisories regarding the obligation to file for insolvency must be provable
  • Stricter requirements: Current Federal Court of Justice (BGH) case law and StaRUG heighten duties of care
  • Legal protective effect: Only applies if qualified, timely warnings are issued

Advisor Liability for Delayed Insolvency Filings: Fundamentals and Risks

Delay in filing for insolvency is among the most common corporate criminal offenses. While the obligations of managing directors are clearly defined—particularly the duty to file an insolvency petition under Section 15a of the German Insolvency Code (InsO) to avoid delayed filing—there is also a significant liability risk for advisors. Advisor liability for delayed insolvency filings primarily impacts tax advisors and statutory auditors who assist companies facing crisis.

Key Takeaways:

  • Tax advisors may face both civil and criminal liability
  • The duty to advise upon recognizable insolvency is critical
  • Active support may constitute aiding and abetting a delayed insolvency filing
  • Comprehensive documentation of all advisories is essential
  • StaRUG has expanded liability risks

Important: While the managing directors of legal entities subject to the filing obligation under Section 15a InsO—such as a GmbH, AG, UG, commercial association, or foundation—are required to file for insolvency, advisors are subject to duties to inform and warn, the breach of which carries liability consequences.

When Does a Tax Advisor Have a Duty to Inform?

According to BGH case law, a duty to inform arises when:

  • The advisor becomes aware of circumstances indicating a state of insolvency—this also applies if these circumstances arise from findings outside the specific scope of the engagement
  • The state of insolvency is recognizable to a diligent advisor—the tax advisor is obligated to perform accurate work and provide a plausible presentation of the findings to the client
  • The client may not recognize the crisis signals—this particularly applies when an impending state of insolvency is obvious to the tax advisor
Warning signs of insolvency

Typical indicators that trigger a duty to inform:

  1. Persistent account overdrafts
  2. Accumulation of payment reminders and enforcement measures
  3. Non-payment of taxes and social security contributions
  4. Negative equity development
  5. Persistent loss situation, particularly evident from the annual financial statements

Practical tip: The duty to inform extends not only to a potential state of insolvency, but also to the resulting obligations of the legal entity’s managing director.

Insolvency and Criminal Liability of the Advisor: Aiding and Abetting Delayed Insolvency Filings

Tax advisors may incur criminal liability through:

  • Aiding and abetting a delayed insolvency filing pursuant to Sections 830, 840 BGB in conjunction with Section 823 BGB, Section 15a (4) InsO, and Section 27 StGB.
  • Aiding and abetting bankruptcy pursuant to Sections 283 et seq. in conjunction with Section 27 StGB
  • In severe cases: co-perpetration

Requirements for criminal liability for aiding and abetting a delayed insolvency filing:

  1. Intentional, unlawful principal offense committed by the managing director
  2. Intentional act of assistance by the advisor
  3. Causality between the assistance and the principal offense
  4. Intent on the part of the advisor regarding both the principal offense and the act of assistance

Typical forms of criminal aiding and abetting:

  • Manipulated balance sheets to conceal the state of insolvency
  • Active advice aimed at avoiding the filing of an insolvency petition
  • Inaccurate going-concern forecasts
  • Concealment of corporate assets

For further details on criminal consequences, please read our article on Penalties for Delayed Insolvency Filings.

Delayed insolvency filing advisor liability

Civil Liability Risks

Civil liability can arise from several directions:

1. Claims by the client:

  • Damage claims arising from breach of contract (Sections 280 (1), 675 (1), 241 (2) BGB) due to a breach of the duty to inform and warn (additionally referencing Section 252 (1) No. 2 HGB)
  • Assertion of claims by the insolvency administrator
  • Encompasses dividend quota damages resulting from the delayed filing

2. Claims by new creditors:

  • Tort claims under Section 823 (2) BGB in conjunction with Section 15a InsO
  • Detrimental reliance damages of creditors who contracted after the state of insolvency occurred
  • Can encompass the total default on claims

3. Claims by the tax authorities:

  • In the event of involvement in tax evasion
  • Liability under Section 71 AO for unpaid taxes
  • Criminal liability under Section 266a StGB (withholding and embezzlement of social security contributions)

The scope of liability can threaten the advisor’s livelihood and includes:

  • Damages resulting from deepening insolvency
  • Full damages incurred by new creditors
  • Legal and procedural costs
  • Personal unlimited liability

Special rules apply to sole proprietors. Learn more in our article Delayed Insolvency Filings for Sole Proprietors & Private Individuals.

Protection Strategies for Advisors

1. Documentation of all advisories:

  • Written advisories upon the very first signs of crisis
  • Meeting minutes signed by the client
  • Registered mail with return receipt for critical notices
  • Regular updates if the crisis persists

2. Clear delineation of the engagement:

  • Precise definition of the advisory scope—noting that any findings arising outside the specific engagement must also be pointed out if they suggest a potential duty to file for insolvency under Section 15a (1) InsO
  • Exclusion of insolvency maturity reviews in standard engagements
  • Recommendation of specialized attorneys and insolvency practitioners
  • Clear demarcation from legal advice

3. Systematic monitoring:

  • “Crisis traffic light system” in client file management
  • Defined escalation tiers
  • Prompt disclosure of insights that emerge during the preparation of annual financial statements
  • Regular internal case reviews
  • Systematic evaluation of key financial indicators

4. Insurance coverage:

  • Review of coverage scope
  • Adjustment of coverage limits
  • Compliance with exclusion clauses
  • Timely notification of potential claims
The protective effect of proper documentation during insolvency

Protective Effect of Proper Advisories and Documentation

Legally compliant fulfillment of the duties to inform and warn develops an essential protective effect for tax advisors and statutory auditors. This protective effect operates across multiple levels:

Civil law protective effect:

  • Exclusion of liability toward the client
  • Defense against recourse claims brought by the insolvency administrator
  • Protection against claims asserted by harmed new creditors
  • Exoneration on causation issues through substantiated proof of having fulfilled warning and notification duties

Criminal law protective effect:

  • Dismissal of aiding and abetting allegations due to lack of intent
  • Documented advisories and proof of professional diligence serving as grounds for exonerating evidence
  • Prevention of allegations of intentional assistance

Professional law protective effect:

  • Fulfillment of professional duties of care
  • Avoidance of professional disciplinary sanctions
  • Protection of professional licensure
  • Proof of conduct conforming to professional standards (lege artis)

Important: Full protection is only afforded by qualified advisories—these must be specific, written, tailored to the recipient, verifiable, and timely. If insolvency has been reached, the decisive circumstances must be explicitly identified. With regard to impending criminal liability for delayed insolvency filing, a mere passing reference to filing an insolvency petition or preparing an over-indebtedness balance sheet is insufficient.

Recent Case Law (2023–2025)

Jurisprudence has developed dynamically:

Federal Court of Justice (BGH), Judgment of November 15, 2023 – IV ZR 277/22

In this decision, the Federal Court of Justice addressed the extent to which a tax advisor is liable for entrepreneurial risks, particularly when involved in business management decisions. The BGH clarified that a breach in the realm of entrepreneurial risk occurs when the tax advisor either acts entrepreneurially within a third-party company or allows personal investment decisions to influence professional conduct. This highlights the critical importance of a clear division between advisory services and entrepreneurial involvement to minimize liability risks.

Higher Regional Court (OLG) Düsseldorf, Judgment of September 24, 2024 – I-23 U 217/22

The Higher Regional Court of Düsseldorf ruled that tax advisors bear a duty to inform even outside a narrow engagement relationship if they identify signs of insolvency. This means advisors are required to inform their clients of potential duties to file for insolvency, even if this was not expressly agreed upon in the engagement letter. The specific mandate does not limit potential liability risks in this regard.

Literature Reference: “The Duty to File for Insolvency in Cases of Over-Indebtedness” A comprehensive overview of the obligations and risks associated with the duty to file for insolvency upon over-indebtedness is provided in the work “Die Insolvenzantragspflicht bei Überschuldung.” This publication offers detailed insights into the legal framework and serves as an invaluable resource for advisors.

Recent case law

Case Studies from Our Attorneys’ Legal Practice

Case 1: Successful Defense Against Insolvency Administrator Claims

A tax advisor was able to demonstrate that they had:

  • Provided written advisories at an early stage
  • Recommended consulting an insolvency law specialist
  • Documented all formal warnings
  • Established a clear delineation of the engagement scope

Case 2: Dismissal of an Investigation Procedure

A statutory auditor was able to substantiate that:

  • Their going-concern forecast was prepared with methodologically correct standards
  • Prospects for restructuring still existed at the time of the review
  • They had documented the limitations of the forecast
  • They had no knowledge of the subsequent deterioration

Case 3: Liability Limitation Through Settlement

Where a breach of the duty to inform had occurred, liability was successfully limited through:

  • Partial acknowledgment of claims
  • Disputing the causal relationship
  • Settlement negotiations

FAQ on Advisor Liability for Delayed Insolvency Filings

Can a tax advisor face criminal prosecution for failing to recognize a state of insolvency?

Criminal liability requires intent. Merely failing to recognize insolvency generally does not constitute a criminal offense. The situation is different in cases of deliberate blindness or active concealment.

How specific must an advisory notice be formulated?

An effective notice must:

  • Explicitly address the potential state of insolvency
  • Specify the legal consequences
  • Emphasize the necessity of a formal examination
  • Provide a concrete recommendation for action
  • Be delivered in writing
Is a tax advisor liable if the managing director fails to file for insolvency despite being warned?

If verifiable, specific notice was given, liability is generally excluded. Proper documentation is decisive.

Does liability exist toward creditors?

Yes, under certain circumstances:

  • Toward new creditors
  • In the event of a breach of a protective statute
  • In cases of active deception
  • In cases of false audit opinions or attestations
How does the StaRUG affect advisors?

The StaRUG expands advisors’ obligations:

  • Duty to inform about pre-insolvency restructuring options
  • Heightened documentation requirements
  • Expanded notification obligations
  • Specific advisory duties regarding the preventive restructuring framework

Conclusion – Avoiding Delayed Insolvency Filings and Advisor Liability

Advisor liability for delayed insolvency filings has become a substantial risk for tax advisors. Jurisprudence has progressively tightened requirements, while StaRUG has introduced further duties.

Key Findings:

  1. Comprehensive duties to inform upon recognizable crisis signals
  2. Documentation as the key to preventing liability
  3. Criminal liability risks in cases of active support
  4. Duties to inform and warn can also be triggered by insights outside the specific scope of engagement, increasing liability risks
  5. Clear delineation of engagement scope is essential
  6. Heightened requirements under StaRUG

Recommendations:

  • Establish systematic early crisis detection
  • Maintain proactive, transparent communication with the client
  • Build an interdisciplinary network of experts
  • Monitor ongoing case law
  • Optimize professional liability insurance coverage
  • Exercise diligent client selection
Table of Contents
Consultation via Video Conference
Our attorneys provide personal consultations regardless of your location – via secure video conferencing, throughout Germany.
Schedule an Appointment
Ihr Kontakt zu uns

Schildern Sie uns Ihren Fall vertrau­lich

Schildern Sie kurz, was passiert ist und ob Fristen oder Termine laufen. Wir melden uns in der Regel innerhalb von 24 Stunden, um das weitere Vorgehen und die benötigten Unterlagen zu klären.
Call directly
The information provided in the contact form will be collected and processed. Your data is transmitted in encrypted form and will not be shared with third parties.