Tax Liability in Preventive Detention?

April 21, 2024
|
in Criminal Law
in Tax Law
|
by Dr. Anthea Pitschel

If there is one thing the German state takes seriously, it is the protection and enforcement of tax law—a stereotype whose veracity may have been shaken in light of the numerous Cum-Ex scandals, but which is confirmed once again in the following case.

The Fiscal Court of Münster recently had to address, on the one hand, the question already settled by the highest courts as to whether the earnings of an individual in preventive detention may be taxed at all. On the other hand, the court considered whether such earnings should be classified as income from employment or as other income within the meaning of the German Income Tax Act (EStG).

This question arose in the specific case because the detainee filed a lawsuit against an income tax assessment in which his wage payments were classified as other income.

The detainee sought to have a lump-sum deduction for income-related expenses in the amount of €1,000 applied, arguing that his work in the correctional facility constituted employment pursuant to Section 19 (1) of the Income Tax Act (EStG).

Furthermore, he argued that his activity could not generally be subject to tax liability, since the employment of prisoners and detainees primarily serves rehabilitation rather than generating income, and that their work is therefore not comparable to a “normal” employment relationship.

In the tax office’s view, the income of an individual in preventive detention constitutes other income within the meaning of Section 22 No. 3 EStG.

The detainee’s work does not arise from an employment relationship, and accordingly there is no entitlement to continued wage payment during illness or to paid vacation. The tax office asserted that it is generally recognized that prison labor is of a public-law nature, and prisoners can therefore not be considered employees. Furthermore, they are only covered by accident and unemployment insurance, but not by health and pension insurance. The tax treatment, it argued, must adhere to these principles.

The Fiscal Court of Münster disagreed, at least in part. In its judgment of September 20, 2023 (14 K 1227/21), the court recognized the existence of an employment relationship between the detainee in preventive detention and the correctional facility, basing its reasoning on the differing legal status of convicts serving prison sentences versus individuals in preventive detention.

Unlike “regular” convicts serving a prison term, individuals in preventive detention are not legally obligated to work. This distinction stems from the differing protective purposes of the two measures. Imprisonment, as the name implies, serves to punish the offender and thus represents primarily a punitive measure.

Preventive detention is a custodial measure of reform and prevention that may be ordered in addition to a term of imprisonment. In this case, the offender remains in state custody for preventive reasons even after having fully served his sentence—effectively making a form of “special sacrifice” for the general public. For this reason, individuals in preventive detention enjoy certain privileges compared to regular convicts.

Because individuals in preventive detention work voluntarily, they exercise—in the view of the Fiscal Court—a “free business will” in the performance of their activity, which constitutes a decisive criterion for affirming employee status and an employment relationship. Consequently, the earnings of the individual in preventive detention were classified as income from employment pursuant to Section 19 (1) EStG.

From this reasoning of the Fiscal Court, it automatically follows that the detainee’s earnings are subject to tax liability.

In 2021, the Federal Court of Justice established that incarcerated persons are not exempt from tax liability. Filing a tax return is generally feasible and reasonable (BGH, Judgment of January 13, 2021 – 1 StR 120/20).

In the grounds for its decision, the Fiscal Court relied on rulings of the Federal Fiscal Court, which clarified that a special motive on the part of the employer (such as securing rehabilitation) does not preclude the taxability of the earnings. The activity is thus, at least in part, directed toward increasing income through an exchange of performance (BFH, Judgment of September 14, 1999, IX R 88/95, BFHE 189, 424, BStBl II 1999, 776).

In the case decided by the Fiscal Court of Münster, the detainee even used part of the earnings from his activity to provide child support payments to his son—meaning the funds were specifically not used solely to ensure his rehabilitation following release.

Table of Contents
Consultation via Video Conference
Our attorneys provide personal consultations regardless of your location – via secure video conferencing, throughout Germany.
Schedule an Appointment
Ihr Kontakt zu uns

Schildern Sie uns Ihren Fall vertrau­lich

Schildern Sie kurz, was passiert ist und ob Fristen oder Termine laufen. Wir melden uns in der Regel innerhalb von 24 Stunden, um das weitere Vorgehen und die benötigten Unterlagen zu klären.
Call directly
The information provided in the contact form will be collected and processed. Your data is transmitted in encrypted form and will not be shared with third parties.