
Tax assessment proceedings and criminal proceedings are often closely intertwined. In many cases, tax audits and criminal tax investigations can hardly be separated from one another.
The resulting dilemma raises the question of which provisions take precedence in the event of a conflict—the regulations of the Fiscal Code (tax assessment proceedings) or those of the Code of Criminal Procedure (criminal proceedings)?
Section 393 of the German Fiscal Code (AO) governs the relationship between criminal proceedings and tax assessment proceedings. Pursuant to Section 393 (1) sentence 1 AO, the rights and obligations of taxpayers and the tax authorities in tax assessment proceedings and criminal proceedings are determined by the rules applicable to the respective proceedings.
In principle, the Fiscal Code assumes the independence and equal standing of both proceedings, meaning that the taxpayer remains obligated to provide information and cooperate in tax assessment proceedings even if parallel criminal tax proceedings are underway.
A limitation to this presumption is set forth in Section 393 (1) sentence 2 AO in the form of a statutory provision stipulating that enforcement measures under tax law are inadmissible if there is a risk of self-incrimination regarding a tax offense or regulatory infraction.
Consequently, once criminal tax proceedings have been initiated, the taxpayer’s cooperation in tax investigation proceedings can no longer be compelled—because no one is required to incriminate themselves (nemo tenetur se ipsum accusare).
This means that the defendant in criminal proceedings is not required to assist in resolving the alleged offense and may refuse to provide any statement regarding the matter. The defendant’s right to remain silent regarding the charges is one of the fundamental principles of the rule of law in criminal and administrative fine proceedings. No one is obliged to contribute to their own conviction.
Beyond the right to remain silent, the defendant is entitled to refuse any active cooperation in their own conviction. They are therefore not required to surrender evidentiary material, as it makes no legal difference whether their conviction is facilitated through coerced statements or through the compelled production of documents. The defendant has a right to passivity and is merely obliged to tolerate procedural investigative measures.
The right to remain silent and the freedom from compelled cooperation are specific manifestations of the general and comprehensive privilege against self-incrimination. This right has constitutional status, as it derives from the principle of the rule of law (Art. 20 (3) of the Basic Law [GG]) and the right to respect for human dignity (Art. 1 (1), Art. 2 (1) GG). It follows from Art. 2 (1) GG in conjunction with Art. 1 GG that it would be unreasonable and incompatible with human dignity to exert coercion requiring an individual to provide the basis for their own criminal conviction through their own statements.
However, because the obligations to cooperate under tax law persist, a conflict with the defendant’s right to remain silent may arise whenever the underlying facts are relevant to both tax law and criminal law.
The privilege against self-incrimination under criminal law and the tax obligations to provide information and cooperate directly clash when the proper fulfillment of tax obligations forces a taxpayer to disclose information that provides grounds for criminal offenses committed by them. This creates a predicament, as the taxpayer cannot exercise their privilege against self-incrimination without violating their duties in the tax assessment proceedings.
Because a taxpayer cannot simultaneously be required to fulfill their disclosure and cooperation obligations under tax law while their constitutionally protected right not to assist in their own conviction is respected, a significant tension arises. Resolving this tension raises the question of which procedural principle must be given priority in cases of conflict.
Section 393 AO is specifically designed to resolve this very conflict between the privilege against self-incrimination in criminal law and the statutory disclosure and cooperation obligations in tax law.
In this respect, the taxpayer is granted a targeted right to remain silent; that is, their obligations to cooperate under tax law formally remain in place even if there is a risk of self-incrimination, but they can no longer be enforced through administrative coercive measures.

