Theft under Section 242 StGB: What are the penalties?

July 24, 2026
|
in Criminal Law
|
by Dr. Anthea Pitschel

Theft and Penalties: Key Facts at a Glance

  • Penalties for simple theft: Under Section 242 of the German Criminal Code (StGB), penalties include a fine or imprisonment for up to five years. Attempted theft is also a punishable offense.
  • Theft as a first-time offender: A lack of prior convictions can have a favorable effect. A dismissal of the case or a small fine is possible depending on the evidence and circumstances, but not guaranteed.
  • Value of the item: There is no fixed sentencing table for theft up to 100, 200, 500, or 1,000 euros. The value is an important factor, but not the sole deciding one.
  • Particularly serious case of theft: In a particularly serious case under Section 243 StGB, the statutory sentencing range generally spans from three months to ten years of imprisonment.
  • Theft involving weapons, gang theft, and residential burglary: Section 244 StGB generally provides for imprisonment from six months to ten years.
  • Summons or hearing questionnaire: Do not provide any statements on the matter before the investigation file has been reviewed. You are generally not required to comply with an ordinary police summons as a suspect.
  • Goal of the defense: Depending on the evidence, the defense can work toward a dismissal of the proceedings, the avoidance of an increased sentencing range, or the lowest possible sanction.

A summons, a hearing questionnaire, or a summary penalty order for theft often comes unexpectedly for those affected. In addition to a fine or imprisonment, professional consequences and an entry in the criminal record (certificate of conduct) may be feared.

The actual penalty for theft cannot be determined solely by the value of the item. The decisive factors are the precise legal classification, the evidence, possible prior convictions, and personal circumstances. Especially when facing an accusation of serious theft under Section 243 or Section 244 StGB, it should be examined early on whether the requirements for the increased sentencing range are actually met.

Initially, do not make any statements regarding the matter to the police. A statement should only be made after reviewing the investigation file and on the basis of a coordinated defense strategy.

When does theft under Section 242 StGB occur?

According to Section 242 StGB, anyone who takes a movable object belonging to another person with the intent of unlawfully appropriating it for themselves or a third party is liable to prosecution.

The public prosecutor’s office must specifically prove that

  • the item was a movable object belonging to another,
  • the custody of another person was broken,
  • the accused acted intentionally, and
  • there was an unlawful intent to appropriate the item.

Not every instance of taking an item automatically constitutes the offense of theft. Particularly in employment relationships, after a separation, with shared items, or in cases of unclear ownership, it may be doubtful whether the item actually belonged to another and whether an intent to appropriate existed.

The distinction between a non-punishable preparatory act, an attempted theft, and a completed act can also be decisive for the defense.

What is the penalty for theft?

Penalty for simple theft under Section 242 StGB

Simple theft is punished with a fine or imprisonment for up to five years. However, the statutory sentencing range says little about what penalty is to be expected in specific proceedings.

The following circumstances, in particular, may play a role in sentencing:

  • Value and type of the stolen item,
  • Planning and execution of the act,
  • Damage incurred,
  • Relevant or other prior convictions,
  • A single act or multiple charges,
  • Personal and economic circumstances, as well as
  • Restitution of damages and other post-offense behavior.

A blanket statement such as “For 500 euros, there are 30 daily units” would therefore be unprofessional. The specific sanction always depends on the entire facts of the case.

What is the penalty for theft as a first-time offender?

Anyone who has not previously come to the attention of the criminal justice system regularly has a more favorable starting position than a repeat offender with relevant prior convictions. However, this does not mean that proceedings are automatically dismissed.

In the case of simple theft, manageable damage, and a lack of prior convictions, the following outcomes are particularly possible depending on the individual case:

  • Dismissal for lack of sufficient suspicion,
  • Dismissal due to insignificance,
  • Dismissal upon fulfillment of a condition,
  • Summary penalty order with a fine, or
  • Conviction to a fine after a main hearing.

A dismissal under Section 153 or Section 153a StPO is not an automatic consequence of a low value. The decisive factors are the evidence, potential guilt, the public interest in prosecution, and the personal situation of the accused.

What is the penalty for theft up to 100, 200, or 500 euros?

The amounts of 100, 200, 500, or 1,000 euros do not constitute statutory sentencing levels. A higher value can have an aggravating effect on the penalty. Conversely, a low value does not automatically lead to a dismissal of the proceedings.

In the case of low-value items, Section 248a StGB may play a role. According to this, simple theft of a low-value item is generally only prosecuted upon request, unless the public prosecutor’s office intervenes ex officio due to a special public interest.

In addition to the value, other circumstances can be significant. These include, for example, prior convictions, repeated acts, a professional/commercial approach, overcoming a security device, or committing the act as a member of a gang.

If the accusation concerns an incident in a supermarket, a drugstore, a hardware store, or at a self-checkout, you will find further information in our article on the penalty for shoplifting.

What penalty do repeat offenders face?

Relevant prior convictions can significantly reduce the chances of a dismissal and lead to a higher fine or imprisonment. It is particularly relevant whether previous convictions also concerned property offenses and whether a previous probation is still active.

Multiple thefts within a short period can also significantly change the assessment. In such cases, it should be examined whether all charges are actually provable and whether they were correctly assessed legally as independent acts.

Particularly serious case of theft under Section 243 StGB

The term “serious theft” is used colloquially for various situations. Legally, a distinction must be made between a particularly serious case under Section 243 StGB and the qualified forms of theft under Section 244 StGB.

A particularly serious case under Section 243 StGB may be considered, for example, if the accused is alleged to have

  • broken into or entered a building, a business premises, or another enclosed space,
  • used a false key,
  • overcome a locked container or a special protective device, or
  • acted on a commercial/professional basis.

The sentencing range generally spans from three months to ten years of imprisonment. However, the presence of a standard example does not necessarily lead to the application of the increased sentencing range in every case.

For the defense, it is therefore crucial whether the alleged standard example can actually be proven and whether the overall circumstances justify the assumption of a particularly serious case.

Serious theft as a first-time offender

A particularly serious case of theft can be assumed even for a first-time offender. The lack of prior convictions does not eliminate the standard example. However, they can have an effect on sentencing and the question of whether a prison sentence can be suspended on probation or, under certain conditions, a fine can be imposed.

Especially with first-time offenders, it should not be prematurely assumed that the serious theft assumed by the police or public prosecutor’s office has been correctly classified legally. Simply refuting a standard example can lead to only the more favorable sentencing range for simple theft being applicable.

Is a fine possible for particularly serious theft?

Section 243 StGB generally provides for imprisonment from three months to ten years. Nevertheless, a fine is not excluded in every constellation.

If the court concludes that a prison sentence of less than six months would be appropriate and a short prison sentence is not indispensable, it can impose a fine under the conditions of Section 47 (2) StGB.

Whether this possibility exists depends on the legal classification and the specific sentencing circumstances.

Theft with weapons, gang theft, and residential burglary under Section 244 StGB

Section 244 StGB specifically covers

  • theft with a weapon or another dangerous tool,
  • carrying a tool or means to overcome potential resistance,
  • gang theft with the involvement of another gang member, and
  • burglary or entry into a residence.

The regular sentencing range spans from six months to ten years of imprisonment. In less serious cases, the law provides for imprisonment from three months to five years.

If the residential burglary concerns a permanently used private apartment, the sentencing range spans from one year to ten years of imprisonment.

When does theft with weapons occur?

For theft with weapons, the weapon does not have to be used. According to the law, simply carrying it during the act can be sufficient.

In practice, difficult questions of distinction arise primarily with knives, tools, and other objects that could be assessed as dangerous tools. Decisive factors include the nature of the object and the specific possibility of access.

When does gang theft occur?

Not every theft committed jointly is a gang theft. What is required is a connection of several persons for the continued commission of robbery or theft offenses. Furthermore, another gang member must participate in the specific act.

Whether a gang agreement actually existed is often a central question of evidence. Acting together in only a single act is not automatically sufficient.

Is a fine possible under Section 244 StGB?

In the regular sentencing range of Section 244 (1) StGB, only imprisonment from six months to ten years is provided for. A fine is generally not considered within this sentencing range.

The situation may be assessed differently in a less serious case under Section 244 (3) StGB. This starts at three months of imprisonment. Under the conditions of Section 47 (2) StGB, a fine can then also be imposed.

Whether a less serious case exists depends on an overall assessment. Relevant factors can include, for example, the specific danger, the role of the accused, the value of the loot, a lack of prior convictions, and other circumstances of the individual case.

Attempted theft: Is the attempt also punishable?

Attempted theft is also punishable under Section 242 (2) StGB. The decisive factor is whether, according to the accused’s conception, they had already directly commenced the act or whether there was merely a non-punishable preparatory act.

The distinction can be difficult, for example, when attempting to open a lock, when entering a property, or when preparing tools. If the further execution of the act is voluntarily abandoned or the completion is prevented, a withdrawal from the attempt that exempts from punishment may also be considered.

Wrongfully accused of theft

Not every theft accusation is based on clear evidence. Accusations often arise after personal conflicts, separations, labor law disputes, or in cases of unresolved ownership.

Possible defense approaches can include:

  • The item was the property of the accused.
  • The owner had consented to the taking.
  • There was a right of use or access.
  • An intent to appropriate cannot be proven.
  • Witnesses perceived the process incompletely or incorrectly.
  • Video recordings do not allow for reliable identification.
  • The time of the act or the location can be refuted.
  • Incriminating statements are contradictory.

Keep messages, invoices, contracts, photos, and other documents that can clarify the facts. Do not delete or change any data and do not try to coordinate with incriminating witnesses regarding their testimony.

Theft in the workplace

A theft accusation in the workplace can have significant labor law and professional consequences in addition to the criminal proceedings. Termination without notice, claims for damages, and damage to reputation may be threatened.

In such cases, it is often not clear who objects belong to and whether taking them was permitted. This can be problematic, for example, with tools, work materials, scrap metal, medication, electronics, cash, or discarded items.

Ill-considered explanations to the employer or the police can later be disadvantageous in both criminal proceedings and labor law proceedings.

Is theft entered into the certificate of conduct?

A conviction for theft is generally stored in the Federal Central Criminal Register. However, it does not necessarily appear in the simple certificate of conduct.

A first-time fine of no more than 90 daily units is generally not included in the simple certificate of conduct if no other penalty is entered in the Federal Central Criminal Register. In the case of multiple entries, higher penalties, or special certificates of conduct, the assessment may be different.

Especially for employees in the public service, persons with professional reliability requirements, and foreign nationals, even supposedly minor sanctions can have a significant impact. These possible collateral consequences must be taken into account in the defense strategy.

Received a summons for theft: What should be done now?

Do not make any statements to the police

As a suspect, you have the right to remain silent. You do not have to prove your innocence to the police and should not spontaneously explain the facts by telephone or in writing.

Even supposedly exculpatory statements can create new contradictions or provide the investigative authorities with information that was not previously known.

Further information can be found in our article on police summons as a suspect.

Do not attend a police appointment unprepared

You are generally not required to comply with an ordinary police summons as a suspect. The situation is different, in particular, for a summons by the public prosecutor’s office or the court.

We handle communication with the investigative authorities and inform them that no statement will be made for the time being. We then apply for inspection of the files.

Review the investigation file first

A sound defense strategy requires knowing

  • who filed the report,
  • what statement the person filing the report made,
  • which witnesses were named,
  • whether video recordings or other evidence exist,
  • what exact sequence of events is alleged, and
  • how the public prosecutor’s office classifies the accusation legally.

Only after inspection of the files in the investigation proceedings should it be decided whether to remain silent or submit a written statement.

Observe deadlines for a summary penalty order

If a summary penalty order has already been served, an appeal can be lodged within two weeks of service. After the deadline has expired, the summary penalty order is generally equivalent to a final judgment.

Further information can be found on our page regarding defense options against a summary penalty order.

Theft by juveniles and young adults

Juvenile criminal law applies to juveniles between the ages of 14 and 17. For young adults between 18 and 20, juvenile criminal law can also be applied depending on their personal maturity and the circumstances of the act.

In juvenile criminal law, the focus is on the educational concept. Possible consequences include directives, work requirements, juvenile detention, or, in more serious cases, a juvenile sentence.

Further information can be found on our page regarding defense in juvenile criminal proceedings.

How we defend you against a theft accusation

Defense does not only begin at the main hearing. Especially in the investigation proceedings, there are often the best opportunities to influence the further course of events.

We specifically handle for you

  • communication with the police and public prosecutor’s office,
  • the cancellation of a police summons,
  • the application for and evaluation of the investigation file,
  • the examination of the suspicion and the evidence,
  • the legal distinction between Section 242, Section 243, and Section 244 StGB,
  • the examination of possible procedural errors,
  • the preparation of a written statement, if this is useful,
  • negotiations regarding a dismissal or another termination of proceedings, as well as
  • defense in summary penalty proceedings and in the main hearing.

Our goal is a solution that not only takes the criminal sanction into account but also limits professional, economic, and personal consequences as much as possible.

We advise and defend clients nationwide. Consultations can take place in person in Göttingen as well as by telephone or video conference.

Further information can be found on our page regarding nationwide criminal defense.

Hire a criminal defense lawyer for theft now

Have you received a summons, a hearing questionnaire, an indictment, or a summary penalty order for theft? Initially, do not make any statements regarding the matter.

Our specialist lawyers for criminal law will examine the specific accusation, apply for inspection of the files, and develop a defense strategy tailored to your case. We represent you nationwide and handle communication with the investigative authorities.

Frequently Asked Questions about Penalties for Theft

What penalty does a first-time offender get for theft?

This cannot be answered in a general way. In the case of simple theft, a lack of prior convictions, and manageable damage, a dismissal or a fine may be considered. However, the evidence and all circumstances of the individual case are decisive.

Can theft proceedings be dismissed?

Yes. A dismissal can occur, for example, for lack of sufficient suspicion, due to insignificance, or upon fulfillment of a condition. However, there is no entitlement to a dismissal.

Do I have to appear for a police summons?

As a suspect, you are generally not required to comply with an ordinary police summons. Different rules apply for a summons by the public prosecutor’s office or a court. Regardless of this, you do not have to make any statements on the matter.

Can a fine be imposed for serious theft?

In a particularly serious case under Section 243 StGB, a fine may be legally possible under the conditions of Section 47 (2) StGB. Under Section 244 (1) StGB, a prison sentence of at least six months is generally provided for. A fine is only considered there in special constellations of a less serious case.

Is attempted theft punishable?

Yes. Section 242 (2) StGB also declares the attempt to be punishable. Whether an attempt or only a non-punishable preparatory act has already occurred depends on the specific sequence of events.

Is a fine for theft entered into the certificate of conduct?

A first-time fine of no more than 90 daily units is generally not included in the simple certificate of conduct if no other penalty is entered in the Federal Central Criminal Register. However, there are exceptions.

What should I do if I am wrongfully accused?

Do not make a spontaneous statement to the police. Secure exculpatory messages, invoices, contracts, and other documents. After inspection of the files, a targeted statement can be made regarding the accusations and possible contradictions.

Table of Contents
Consultation via Video Conference
Our attorneys provide personal consultations regardless of your location – via secure video conferencing, throughout Germany.
Schedule an Appointment
Ihr Kontakt zu uns

Schildern Sie uns Ihren Fall vertrau­lich

Schildern Sie kurz, was passiert ist und ob Fristen oder Termine laufen. Wir melden uns in der Regel innerhalb von 24 Stunden, um das weitere Vorgehen und die benötigten Unterlagen zu klären.
Call directly
The information provided in the contact form will be collected and processed. Your data is transmitted in encrypted form and will not be shared with third parties.