The Case: Escalated Arrest with Far-Reaching Consequences
In July 2021, a serious police operation occurred in Göttingen city center. A heavily intoxicated 31-year-old offered massive resistance to police measures. The police officer, now 35, felt compelled to restrain the aggressive man together with three colleagues. During this, the arrested person was struck – an incident documented by bodycam footage and later published online.
The public prosecutor then filed charges of bodily harm in office. A difficult time began for the affected police officer: in addition to the criminal proceedings, he had to endure massive hostility and was even forced to move out of Göttingen with his family.
Two Instances – Two Acquittals
First Acquittal at the Göttingen Local Court (2023)
The Göttingen Local Court already concluded that the police officer had acted in an extreme exceptional situation. According to the officer’s statement, the arrested person had clutched him so tightly that he could not breathe – he feared for his life. The court recognized that the police officer may have exceeded the limits of self-defense “out of confusion, fear, or terror” (§ 33 StGB) and acquitted him.
Confirmation by the Göttingen Regional Court (2025)
In the appeal proceedings, the Local Court’s assessment was not only confirmed but interpreted even more clearly in favor of the police officer. A police trainer from Hesse, called in as an expert, attested that the accused’s conduct was entirely in accordance with regulations. The blows were deemed proportionate as a police coercive measure to restore safety.
The Importance of Professional Criminal Defense
This case is an exemplary demonstration of the importance of specialized defense for police officers. Attorney Anthea Pitschel of MPP Lawyers successfully conducted the defense through both instances. “It was very important for my client that his assessment of the situation is now also supported by the court,” she explained after the final acquittal.
The legal processing of such cases requires not only profound knowledge of criminal law but also a deep understanding of police operational situations and the legal framework of police action. MPP Lawyers successfully contributed precisely this expertise in this case.
Impact of the Proceedings
The years-long criminal proceedings left deep marks on the acquitted police officer. In his closing statement before the court, he vividly described the burdens on himself and his family. The media’s prejudgment, hostility, and forced relocation show the price police officers sometimes have to pay for performing their duties.
The officer no longer works in patrol duty today – a consequence that gives pause for thought when he himself asks: “Who even wants to do that anymore?”
Legal Classification: Self-Defense and Police Force
The case raises important questions about the tension between necessary police force and the limits of the rule of law. The Regional Court clarified: blows can be a legitimate police coercive measure in extreme situations if all milder means have failed. This assessment was confirmed by the expert, who evaluated the measures as a graduated escalation.
The legal basis for this is § 33 StGB, which regulates the so-called excess of self-defense. This privileges individuals who, in a self-defense situation, exceed the limits of necessary defense out of confusion, fear, or terror. In the present case, the court recognized precisely this exceptional psychological situation in the accused police officer, who, according to his own statement, felt mortal fear when he was choked by the arrested person.
Critical voices, such as that of criminal law expert Gunnar Duttge from the Georg-August University Göttingen, however, warn against an overly broad interpretation of self-defense rights for police officers. His concerns are particularly directed at the expectation that trained officers should have higher stress resistance. This legal debate shows how complex the legal assessment of police actions in extreme situations is and underscores the importance of expert defense in such proceedings.
Conclusion: An Important Signal for the Police
The final acquittal sends an important signal to all police officers: those who act in exceptional situations and maintain proportionality can rely on the protection of the rule of law – provided they have competent defense by their side.
Are you a police officer facing criminal charges?
The law firm Mügge, Dr. Pitschel & Partner has many years of experience in defending police officers. We understand the particular challenges of your profession and are fully committed to protecting your rights.
MPP Lawyers – Your Strong Partner in Difficult Times.
